
Ask ten people in the Dubai market what happens when a buyer pulls out after signing a Form F and ten of them will give you the same answer: the seller keeps the 10%.
It is the most confidently repeated sentence in the secondary market, and it describes an outcome rather than a mechanism. The outcome is sometimes right. The mechanism that would produce it is not what people think it is, and the gap between the two is where months of a seller's time disappears.
Two things decide what really happens, and neither of them is the sentence everyone repeats.
Who Is Holding the Cheque, and What Are They Allowed to Do With It?
Start here, because it settles more arguments than the law does. Under the standard Form F terms, the security deposit cheque is held on trust with the agent, and may not be disposed of, cashed, or released without written instructions from both the buyer and the seller. Where entitlement is disputed, it is not released to either party except under a court order identifying who is entitled to it.
Read that again from the seller's side. The buyer has defaulted, you are plainly in the right, and the instrument that is supposed to compensate you is a piece of paper that your own agent is contractually forbidden to hand over without the signature of the person who just defaulted on you.
A buyer who is content to walk away is usually also content not to sign anything. That alone converts an entitlement into a dispute, and it is the single most under-reported fact about Form F in Dubai.
It also explains the market's most common informal outcome: a negotiated split. Sellers who are told they will spend eight months and a legal budget to recover 10% of a sale price very often settle for a fraction of it within a fortnight. That is not a failure of the seller's lawyer. It is the predictable consequence of a release mechanism that requires the defaulting party's cooperation.
Note that the cheque is usually not cashed at all
In practice the 10% is a manager's cheque or personal cheque handed over at signing and left uncashed, not money transferred to the seller. People hear "deposit" and picture funds sitting somewhere. Usually there are no funds anywhere — there is an instrument, held by an agent, pending an event.
That matters for a second reason. A cheque that is eventually presented and bounces is a separate problem with its own machinery: under Article 667 of Federal Decree-Law No. 50 of 2022, a cheque stamped by the bank as unpaid for insufficient funds is an executive instrument, enforceable directly before the execution judge without a substantive claim first. Whether a security cheque held on trust can be deployed that way depends on the terms it was given under, and it is worth specific advice rather than assumption.

Is the Deposit Automatically Forfeited When the Buyer Defaults?
No. Forfeiture is a claim, not a switch. To keep the deposit the seller has to establish a set of facts, and each of them is capable of being contested:
- That the buyer failed to pay the agreed amounts or to complete the transfer on the agreed date.
- That the failure resulted from the buyer's own act or omission.
- That no written extension or amendment moved the date.
- That no enforceable condition in the contract gave the buyer a valid exit.
That last one is where most sellers actually lose. A Form F with a clause making the purchase conditional on mortgage approval, or on a valuation at or above the price, is a contract the buyer may be entitled to exit without penalty when the condition fails. The buyer did not default. The condition did.
This is why the Special Conditions field of the Form F is the most important part of the document. It is a free-text field, it is where financing conditions, long-stop dates and deposit mechanics get written, and it is read by most sellers for thirty seconds after the price has been agreed and the relief has set in.
Does a Failed Mortgage Count as a Valid Excuse?
Not by itself. The Dubai Court of Cassation, in Civil Appeal No. 249 of 2023 decided in May 2024, set out the test for force majeure: the event must be exceptional, sudden, unusual, unforeseeable and unavoidable, and must be something that could not be prevented.
Personal financial difficulty, loss of employment and a declined mortgage application do not meet that standard. They are ordinary commercial risks of the kind a buyer is expected to carry.
The distinction that matters is therefore contractual, not catastrophic. A buyer whose financing fails is protected if the contract made the deal conditional on financing. The same buyer, on a Form F with no such condition, is in default — and arguing force majeure will not rescue them.
Can a Court Reduce the 10%?
Yes, and this is the part of the law that changed recently. The 10% is agreed compensation — a sum the parties fixed in advance instead of proving loss later. UAE law has never treated such a figure as beyond review.
Under the 1985 Civil Code, Article 390(2) let a judge amend the agreed amount in all cases, on the application of either party, so that it equalled the actual prejudice. That discretion was famously broad.
Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, in force since 1 June 2026, replaced it with Article 340, which keeps the power but channels it:
| Direction | Who must prove it | On what grounds |
|---|---|---|
| Reduction of the agreed sum | The debtor, meaning the defaulting party | That the sum is exaggerated, that the obligation was partly performed, or that the creditor contributed to the harm |
| Increase above the agreed sum | The creditor, meaning the innocent party | Fraud or gross negligence |
The direction of travel is toward predictability: enumerated grounds and an allocated burden of proof, rather than open-ended discretion. But the supervisory power itself remains mandatory, and the parties cannot contract out of it.
For a Dubai seller this has a very concrete meaning. A 10% forfeiture is a ceiling, not an entitlement. If the property is relisted and sells a month later at the same price, the loss is a month of carrying costs and some wasted fees — and a defaulting buyer who argues under Article 340 that AED 150,000 is exaggerated against a demonstrable loss of AED 20,000 has a case the court is required to consider.
The corollary is the better news, and sellers rarely act on it: document the loss. Carrying costs, service charges, a lower price achieved on the resale, mortgage interest on a replacement purchase that had to be deferred, the second round of marketing and commission. The seller who arrives with that file is arguing about facts. The seller who arrives with a copy of the Form F and a sense of grievance is arguing about feelings.

What If It Is the Seller Who Pulls Out?
The standard Form F consequence runs the other way: where the seller withdraws without justification, the deposit is returned to the buyer in full.
The buyer's position is often stronger than the seller's, for a reason that has nothing to do with sympathy. The buyer may also seek damages, and may seek specific performance — an order that the sale actually completes. Dubai property is unique by nature, and a court asked to compel the transfer of a specific registered unit is being asked for something coherent in a way that compelling a reluctant buyer to pay rarely is.
Sellers who change their mind because the market moved, or because a better offer arrived, should understand that they are exposed to more than the return of the cheque.

How Does a Form F Get Cancelled Properly?
A dead deal that is never formally unwound is a liability that follows the property.
- Agree the cancellation in writing, signed by both parties, dealing expressly with the deposit cheque and with its physical return. A cancellation that does not say what happens to the cheque has resolved nothing.
- Use the regulator's own step first. RERA operates an Amicable Settlement service for Contract F disputes through Trakheesi — a free, regulator-chaired session before anyone goes to court. It suspends no contractual deadline, so it is a step to take promptly rather than a reason to let time pass.
- Clear the transaction record so the unit is not left showing an active sale against it, and so the Trakheesi permit position is tidy before relisting.
- Settle the commission question deliberately, because it does not go away by itself.
The bill nobody expects
Article 29 of Bylaw No. 85 of 2006 provides that where the contract is revoked, the broker may still claim the fee in accordance with the agreement, unless deception or serious error on the broker's part is proven. And Article 33 keeps each appointing party severally liable for its own share of the commission even where the parties agreed that one of them would pay in full.
So a collapsed deal can arrive with a commission invoice attached, payable by the party who appointed the broker, regardless of what the buyer and seller agreed between themselves about who would pay. A seller negotiating a walk-away settlement with a defaulting buyer should establish the brokerage's position before signing anything, not after.
What To Put in the Form F Before You Sign It
Everything above is an argument for spending twenty minutes on a document most people sign in five.
- A long-stop date with a stated consequence. "On or before" with nothing attached is an aspiration.
- An express financing condition, or an express exclusion of one. Silence here is the single most litigated gap in the Dubai secondary market.
- A named deposit holder and a written release mechanism that does not require the signature of a party who has already defaulted — for example release on a defined event, or escrow with an agreed instruction.
- A clause on whether the deposit is the sole remedy. If it is, the seller has capped their own claim. If it is not, say so expressly.
- Who bears the cost of an extension, because extensions are the normal outcome of a mortgage running late and are far more common than default.
The Short Version
- The standard Form F holds the security cheque on trust with the agent. It cannot be cashed or released without both parties' written instruction or a court order.
- Forfeiture is therefore a claim to be established, not an automatic entitlement.
- A declined mortgage is not force majeure. Per Civil Appeal No. 249 of 2023, the event must be exceptional, sudden, unusual, unforeseeable and unavoidable.
- But a declined mortgage is an exit where the contract made the sale conditional on financing, which is why the Special Conditions field decides most of these disputes.
- Article 340 of the 2025 Civil Code lets a court reduce the agreed sum where the defaulting party proves exaggeration, part performance or contribution by the other side. The 10% is a ceiling.
- Document your actual loss from day one. It is what the figure is measured against.
- Under Article 29 of Bylaw 85 of 2006, the brokerage may still be owed its fee on a revoked contract. Settle that before signing a walk-away.
Frequently Asked Questions
01If a buyer pulls out, does the seller automatically keep the 10% deposit in Dubai?
No. Under the standard Form F the deposit cheque is held on trust with the agent and may not be disposed of, cashed or released without written instructions from both the buyer and the seller, and where entitlement is disputed it is released only under a court order. The seller also has to establish that the buyer failed to complete on the agreed date, that the failure was due to the buyer's own act or omission, that no written extension moved the date and that no contractual condition gave the buyer a valid exit. Forfeiture is a claim to be proved, not a switch that flips on default.
02Can a Dubai court reduce the 10% deposit a seller is claiming?
Yes. The deposit is agreed compensation, and Article 340 of Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, in force since 1 June 2026, allows a court to reduce it where the defaulting party proves that the sum is exaggerated, that the obligation was partly performed, or that the creditor contributed to the harm. An increase above the agreed figure is available only where the innocent party proves fraud or gross negligence. The power is mandatory and cannot be excluded by agreement, so a seller should treat 10% as a ceiling and document the loss actually suffered.
03Is a failed mortgage approval a valid reason for a buyer to walk away?
Only if the contract says so. In Civil Appeal No. 249 of 2023, decided in May 2024, the Dubai Court of Cassation held that force majeure requires an event that is exceptional, sudden, unusual, unforeseeable and unavoidable, and personal financial difficulty, loss of employment and a declined mortgage application do not meet that standard. A buyer is protected where the Form F was made expressly conditional on mortgage approval or on a valuation at or above the agreed price. Without such a condition the same buyer is in default.
04What should go in the Special Conditions section of a Form F?
At a minimum a long-stop date with a stated consequence, an express financing condition or an express exclusion of one, a named deposit holder with a release mechanism that does not depend on the signature of a party who has already defaulted, a clause stating whether the deposit is the seller's sole remedy, and an allocation of who bears the cost of an extension. Extensions are far more common than outright default, and silence on financing is the single most litigated gap in the Dubai secondary market.
05Does the agent still get paid if the sale falls through?
Possibly. Article 29 of Bylaw No. 85 of 2006 provides that where the contract is revoked the broker may still claim the fee in accordance with the agreement, unless deception or serious error on the broker's part is proven. Article 33 separately keeps each appointing party severally liable for its own share of the commission even where the parties agreed that one of them would pay in full. A seller negotiating a walk-away settlement should establish the brokerage's position before signing it rather than afterwards.
06What happens if the seller is the one who refuses to complete?
The standard Form F consequence is the return of the full deposit to the buyer. The buyer may also pursue damages and may seek specific performance, which is an order that the transfer actually takes place. That remedy tends to be more realistic against a seller than against a buyer, because a specific registered unit is unique and an order to transfer it is coherent in a way that an order compelling a reluctant buyer to fund a purchase usually is not.


